July 6, 2012--Navajo lawmakers reject water rights settlement (Denver Post)

Navajo lawmakers have rejected a settlement to recognize the tribe's water rights from the Little Colorado River basin, likely sending the tribe and its Hopi neighbor back to court to resolve their claims. The Tribal Council voted 15-6 against the settlement Thursday during a special session in Window Rock. The vote also puts a stop to legislation in Congress to move the settlement forward because it needed the blessing of both the Navajo and Hopi tribes. "I think it's a missed opportunity," said Jared King, a spokesman for the Navajo Nation. "These things don't come by very often. It's disappointing." Critics saw the settlement as an attack on their aboriginal rights and tilted toward corporate interests. They urged lawmakers to vote it down and continue fighting in court. A case in Apache County had been on hold while the tribes and 30 other entities worked out a settlement decades in the making. Aside from Zuni Pueblo, no other Arizona tribe has acquired rights to the Little Colorado River. Under the settlement, the tribes would have waived further claims to the river basin if the federal government funded more than $300 million in groundwater delivery projects. Kyl had said the settlement would address the water needs of the reservations and provide certainty of the state's water supply for off-reservation communities. Tribes often trade what could be huge water claims for the promise of federal funding to deliver water to tribal communities. A few American Indian water rights cases have been resolved through litigation. Navajo President Ben Shelly ultimately backed the settlement as a way to avoid protracted courtroom battle and guarantee water delivery to tribal communities. He and Tribal Council Speaker Johnny Naize held public hearings across the reservation and received hundreds of comments on the settlement. Shelly said Thursday that he would look for other ways to bring water to the communities on the western side of the reservation.

To view the full article, visit the Denver Post. For a copy of the original article contact the WIP at (970) 247-1302 or stop by the office at 841 East Second Avenue in Durango, Colorado.